Unbeknownst to him, Simon had similar feelings of attraction, and feeling rejected by Edwin, decided to make him the victim of pranks, torments and taunts. This included calling him a homophobic slur because of his quiet, bookish and effeminate character.
One night, while he was sleeping, Edwin was kidnapped by Simon and a handful of bullies and dragged to an abandoned attic. There they tied him up and attempted to scare him by pretending to summon a demon. However, much to their surprise - and horror - the invocation ritual was a success, conjuring Sa'al to the mortal plane. Making quick work of those who summoned him, the demon apologised to Edwin for what he was about to do, dragging the terrified boy to Hell.
When the school discovered he was gone, his disappearance was dressed up as an act of God and swiftly dropped. He spent the next 74 years in Hell until he eventually escaped back to the land of the living.
A lover of detective novels in life, Edwin would use this passion to start the Dead Boy Detective Agency alongside his best friend and crush, Charles Rowland. He took each case seriously, hoping to find clients the justice that was robbed from him.
With the help of Niko Sasaki and Thomas, the Cat King of Port Townsend, Edwin began to come to terms with his sexuality and love himself for who he was. This newfound confidence not only allowed him to confess his love for Charles, but also showed his younger self and his bully - during a meeting in Hell - the compassion and love he couldn't in life.